An Article
Philosophy
In Brief
An exploration of the disturbing, unconventional, and aesthetically appealing philosophy presented through the character of Hannibal Lecter.
Collabs Scholar
Open Access Library
I. The Divine Architect of Chaos
To begin with, Hannibal Lecter is a believer in God. He truly believes that there is a designer for the marvelous architecture of this whole cosmos and universe, from small atoms to supergalaxies. Because this design is marvelous, and no one can deny that; considering plants, the Earth, planets, stars, galaxies, and the whole universe. Each and everything in this universe points out a designer.
And it's not just about the dead matter; take the artistic and aesthetic expression of God in His creation of animals, humans, and their complexity. With all its defects and iterations, man is so much beautiful and sublime (obviously not in a conventional sense).
But Hannibal never denies God, and he believes that he obeys God by imitating Him; he believes that that is the real essence of God, which he tries to imitate. In multiple instances, he exclaims that:
Killing must feel good to God, too. He does it all the time, and are we not created in His image?
Or “God feels powerful when He kills. It’s an exercise of power,” or “God is beyond measure in wanton malice, and matchless in His irony.”
To appreciate God and to acknowledge Him, one must imitate Him, the way a child imitates his mother to gain her grace and affection. As God has created us in His image, so He must want us to be like Him; otherwise, He would not have created us thus. It’s indecent to refuse a gift from high above.
II. The Mirage of Morality
Morality doesn’t concern Hannibal, because he neither entertains nor believes in morality. As he says: “there is no morality, only morale,” which is a bold but a right declaration.
God never created such a thing as good and evil, as he says in one instance that: “Good and Evil have nothing to do with God… typhoid and swans, it all comes from the same place.” God never decreed something as good and evil; it’s humans who persist on it. Moreover, we humans aesthetically standardize them as good and evil, right and wrong. For God, neither there is good nor evil, so it should be for man also. Are we not created in His image?
If a person has gone for hunting, after his first hunt, he would be addicted to it. He would fantasize and imagine it again and again and extract pleasure from it. The pleasure or sense of pleasure depends on different things:
- first, how was the chase;
- second, how much was the distance;
- third, how was the sound if you are using a gun; if a knife, then how was the fight.
The harder the chase, the longer the distance, the fiercer the sound (while using a gun), the greater the fight (if one is using a knife), then the greater and stronger is the pleasure. Furthermore, the sense of power also depends on the quantity of prey as well as the quality of prey.
If one hunted two sparrows in one shot, that’s good, but if one shot five, then it’s great, and so the pleasure increases. Well, that’s quantitative. Qualitatively, if the prey is a rabbit or deer, then the sense of power and consequently the sense of pleasure increases.
In that manner, if the prey is human and that person is stronger, and when one is using a knife rather than a gun, then the sense of power and pleasure heightens immensely and extraordinarily.It’s not killing that he likes; in truth, it’s the power he feels after killing them, and the excitement, adventure, and freedom that he values the most. So is the same with God: “Killing must feel good to God, too. He does it all the time, and are we not created in His image?”
III. Art, the Herd, and the Metamorphosis
When it comes to aesthetics, Hannibal is strict and judgmental. That the world is chaotic and majestic at the same time, and we humans can elevate it through art. So that’s why he admires every kind of art: painting, music, dance, literature, and cuisine.
And tries to eliminate those who are a stain on this cosmic art—meaning the rude people, whom he calls sheep. After killing them, he cooks them in varieties and presents them as a feast. And he turns the most ugliest things into sublime and beautiful. And in that, he imitates God, to carry on the work of God where He left off. And it’s the most interesting part of his philosophy.
Hannibal believes that life and this world is like an empty canvas, and one can paint and should paint anything that one desires. There is no distinction such as good and evil, right and wrong. So that’s why he is against the mass, which he terms as sheep. Because they conform, obey, and cannot surpass, and that’s the reason why he kills them and eats them. As he says to Dr. Chilton that: “I have no interest in understanding sheep, only in eating them.”
But Hannibal draws a clear distinction between sheep and lamb. Lamb is innocent, vulnerable, and traumatized, and he doesn’t want to let the lamb turn into another sheep. So he employs methods and struggle to unleash their power, that the lamb can also break the chains and be fierce like a lion, and beware of one's predatory nature. And in that, he says: “the lamb is becoming the lion,” referring to Will Graham.
IV. Radical Honesty, Curiosity, and Death
His lack of morality and strict aesthetic sense drives Hannibal to love, hate, care, be ruthless, be a monster, and kind, etc., at the same time. He is against a monotonic life, or a strict code of life which is imitation and not creation; a chaotic mode of life he admires, a life full of destruction, construction, and creation. Being sympathetic and at the same time cruel shows his character’s complexity. His relation with Will Graham and Chiyoh shows his difference and indifference towards humans.
Hannibal Lecter is extremely true to oneself. There are things which we cannot expose to people but only to friends; there are things which we cannot tell friends but to oneself; and there are things which we even hide from ourselves. Almost all humans hide a lot of things from themselves; even after knowing them, they suppress them, but not Hannibal, and that’s exactly what makes him stand out.
At one time in conversation with Will Graham, Will says: “A shepherd's dog doesn’t eat the sheep,” to this he replies: “but it wants to.” And then he masterfully concludes underlying the necessity of being true and honest to oneself by saying:
"better to live true to yourself for an instant than to never know it."The thing which really drives Hannibal to those kinda action is curiosity. He is always curious:
- what would happen?
- What would be the outcome?
- How would one behave?
- How would be the relation after this?
- How would be the identity of a person?
In each and every man, hope and curiosity are the main drives towards life, which are unconscious; but in the case of Hannibal, it’s pure conscious curiosity that drives him.
At last, it all boils down to one thing, and that is death. There is only one certainty in history, that’s decadence, and there is only one certainty in life, and that is death. Even Hannibal cannot deny or defy it, and so he embraces it with wide arms. Hannibal considers death as a cure for the burden of immortality. Even just the thought of living for eternity engulfs one.
So, considering the pros and cons, Hannibal famously declares that:
I have always found the idea of death comforting, that my life could end at any moment, which frees me to appreciate the art and beauty of life.
Finis
Thank you for reading.
About the writer & comments ↓Afterword
Hannibal Lecter's Philosophy
About the Writer
Adnan Ishaq
AKHSS Booni
Adnan Ishaq writes for Collabs Scholar.
Comments
Comments are coming soon.